Every Pink Floyd Album Ranked from Worst to Best

Pink Floyd - Wikipedia

15. Ummagumma (1969)

How could you describe this album to someone who has never listened to it? I think you just need to hear it to believe it. This is one of the weirdest, creepiest, freakiest, most random, and most confusing albums to ever exist. Just listen to the track titled, “Several Species of Small Furry Animals Gathered Together in a Cave and Grooving With a Pict,” and you will understand. This album is more or less the band’s first without front man Syd Barrett, and man, his absence is felt. The album starts with a few live versions of some of their earlier hits, but they decided to try and make them even weirder than they already were (weirder does not mean better!). Then, each of the four members tries their hand at making weird sounds and labeling it as music. Wright makes a variety of random noises on “Sysyphus” Waters comes in and injects some actual music into the album with “Grantchester Meadows,” only to follow that up with the weirdest thing of all-time (Several Species). Gilmour actually gets somewhat close to music with “The Narrow Way” (key word – somewhat). Finally, Nick Mason gives us whatever the hell “The Grand Vizier’s Garden Party” is. Some would call these “Sound Collages,” but whatever they are, they are not music, so literally every other album that features music ranks ahead of this one.

14. A Momentary Lapse of Reason (1987)

David Gilmour realized after the release of his 1978 self-titled, debut album that he was not really bringing in the money like he used to when he was a part of Pink Floyd. So, halfway through the recording of his second studio album, he decided, hey, let’s have Nick Mason come in and bang on the drums a couple of times and have Richard Wright play a couple of notes and we will call this a Pink Floyd album. Amongst all of the criticism, refusal to accept the album as Pink Floyd, and lawsuits from Roger Waters himself, this album was released in 1987. Let’s give Gilmour some credit. The man knows how to play the guitar, and this album has a few excellent guitar solos, and, well, it probably sold way more copies than it would have if it were released as a Gilmour solo album. Apart from this, though, the album is a grossly overproduced mess that is littered with 80’s music cliches. Some of the vocal parts on the album, like on “A New Machine” are just plain weird, and not even that Ummagumma-type weird. The overproduction is unbearable at times, and there are moments where the album literally feels like an 80’s disco musical. Just listen to “One Slip” and tell me you do not want to just get up and dance on some roller skates. Yeah, that is not Pink Floyd, sorry. Even the brighter moments like “Learning to Fly” feel far too Pop-y to be Pink Floyd. Thematically, the album is lacking without the influence of Roger Waters, and its no wonder that the band searched for outside help with the songwriting on their next album. This album just does not feel like Pink Floyd.

13. More (Original Film Soundtrack) (1969)

Does this count as a studio album? It’s on this list, but More is actually a film by Barbet Schroeder that came out in 1969, and this is the soundtrack. Despite its status as a soundtrack, this album is quite an important transitional step for the band, as it is technically the first album without Syd Barrett. Because it is a soundtrack, the majority of the album consists of relatively uneventful instrumental tracks. That being said, take nothing away from some of the other tracks seen on this album. For the first time, we get to see Roger Waters at the head of songwriting for the band, and the result is quite interesting. Tracks like “Crying Song,” “Green Is the Colour,” and “Cymbaline” showcase early signs of that Waters songwriting, and “The Nile Song” was even released as a single. This album is often overlooked and sometimes not even considered a studio album, but it has some deep cuts that only the truest of Floyd fans appreciate. Nonetheless, it really does function as a soundtrack, and that prevents it from being any higher on the list.

12. The Endless River (2014)

Don’t give me any silly overproduction, don’t give me any unnecessary commercialization, don’t give me any stupid music cliches, in fact, don’t even give me lyrics. Just give me Gilmour, Wright, and Mason playing their respective instruments. That’s what this album is. Is this a tribute to Richard Wright after his death, or is it just a way to make some more money using the name Pink Floyd? Either way, David Gilmour and Nick Mason threw this album together 20 years after the release of The Division Bell, and it is mainly comprised of some leftover scraps from those sessions. Take this album for what it is. Apart from the last track, “Louder Than Words,” this is a completely instrumental album. It’s never going to rank up there with the great Floyd albums, but Wright, Mason, and Gilmour know how to make some truly beautiful music. This album is worth a listen maybe while you cook dinner or something, but, again, its certainly not one of their greatest.

11. The Division Bell (1994)

Speaking of The Division Bell, here it is. At this point, we are really starting to reach the upper tier of Pink Floyd albums. It felt wrong to put this album all the way down at 11 because truly this is a great album. Its the second effort from the post-Waters Pink Floyd, and it’s truly the only that feels like a group work. Richard Wright and Nick Mason actually played a full role in making this album, and it shows. The outside help they got with the songwriting on this album certainly helps, and there are actual palpable themes in this album, covering the struggles of personal communication in the dawning of the internet age. Tracks like “What Do You Want from Me” and “Poles Apart” feature some brilliant lyrics, and of course, we can never get enough of the Gilmour guitar solos. The songs actually feel like Pink Floyd (probably because Richard Wright and Nick Mason actually did something this time around). “High Hopes” is probably the crowning achievement of this album. It references many of the band’s previous works, and it serves brilliantly as a final farewell for the band. Overall, The Division Bell deserves its place in the star-studded Pink Floyd discography. Yes, it had some outside help, and yes it still does suffer from a bit of overproduction, but its low ranking on this list is less about its shortcomings and more of a testament to the brilliance of the rest of Pink Floyd’s works.

10. Obscured By Clouds (1972)

Pink Floyd once again teamed up again with filmmaker Barbet Schroeder for yet another film soundtrack, but this time, the band was at their experimental peak. This album is sandwiched in the band’s discography between two of their most important albums. In fact, parts of the album were actually recorded while they were recording The Dark Side of the Moon. This album certainly does not function as a soundtrack as much as More did, but still, at times the band’s creativity seems to be somewhat restrained. With that being said, the band was beginning to peak, and many of the tracks reflect this. “The Gold It’s In the…” is a rocking contribution from Gilmour unlike any Pink Floyd song ever. “Wot’s…Uh the Deal?” and “Childhood’s End” are two more excellent performances from Gilmour, and “Stay” is an great contribution from Richard Wright. On “Free Four,” Roger Waters introduces us to some of the themes we will begin to see in Pink Floyd’s music for the next ten years, and for the first time he talks about his father. The album contains excellent music, but its a soundtrack, and this prevents the album from reaching its full potential given when it was released.

9. A Saucerful of Secrets (1968)

This was the last Pink Floyd album to feature Syd Barrett and the first to feature David Gilmour. As Syd slowly went insane, Gilmour was brought in to replace him, although his influence on this album is relatively minimal. With their sophomore album, whether by choice or not, Pink Floyd began to drift away from the signature psych-pop style of Syd Barret that made their debut album so great. The fading influence of Syd can still be seen on “Jugband Blues,” but the rest of the album is a transitional space-rock approach brought about primarily by Roger Waters and Richard Wright, and it works to excellent effect. Wright shines with “Remember a Day” and “See-Saw.” Waters’ shrilling whisper-vocals on “Let There Be More Light” and “Set the Controls for the Heart of the Sun” give the album an uneasy feel that will make the hairs on the back of your neck stand up. Perhaps the less said about the nearly 12 minute title track, the better, but give it credit for being quite possibly the creepiest of all Pink Floyd songs. Overall, this album has a truly important place in the band’s discography as they transitioned into their progressive rock era.

8. Atom Heart Mother (1970)

How in the world did this album come out just eleven months after Ummagumma? This is the album when Pink Floyd finally found their direction after Syd Barrett’s departure. Here is a blog post talking more specifically about that. Seriously, this album actually has music on it; it deserves to be number 1 just for that! All jokes aside, this five-track album is truly brilliant. It starts with a nearly 24 minute long suite comprised of six parts. This suite is really unlike anything Pink Floyd has ever released; it features orchestral and horn sections, choir parts, guitar riffs, and more. It is quite enthralling, and you really just have to listen to it yourself. The middle three tracks are all brilliant individual efforts from Waters, Wright, and Gilmour. Waters’ “If” is an underappreciated acoustic track with evidently maturing lyrics. Wright’s “Summer ’68” is a joyous pop song with a fun hook and catchy melodies. Gilmour’s “Fat Old Sun” is another acoustic track with maturing lyrics, and it showed the world what Gilmour was capable of. Yea, Nick Mason’s “Alan’s Psychedelic Breakfast” starts to head back in the direction of Ummagumma, but do not let that subtract from the rest of the album. Even still, that at least feels musical at some points. This album was an extremely important step up for the band, and we would probably not know Pink Floyd as they are today without it.

7. The Piper at the Gates of Dawn (1967)

This is Syd Barrett. If someone asked you who Syd Barrett was for Pink Floyd, show them this. You could pretty much sum this album up with three letters: L-S-D. In all seriousness, this album takes the idea of psych-rock to a whole new level that even Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band cannot compare to. With some brilliant organ work from Richard Wright and some stellar guitar riffs from Syd Barrett, the album is perfectly silly, dreamy, weird, and psychedelic. Classic hits like “Lucifer Sam” and “Flaming” perfectly embody Syd Barret’s LSD-induced vision. “Bicycle” is an absolute classic Syd song that is just as fun and silly as it is weird and creepy. Roger Waters even gets in on the psychedelic fun with “Take Up Thy Stethoscope and Walk.” “Interstellar Overdrive” is one of Syd’s most notorious works, and it features some excellent guitar-playing, eerie psychedelic sounds, futuristic, space-like undertones, and an encapsulating experiment using stereo sound. Put in some headphones and skip to around 8:35 in, and you will hear one of the craziest uses of stereo of all-time that might make your head explode. You would be hard pressed to find a more psychedelic album than this one, and it truly is the pinnacle of the psych-rock movement.

6. The Final Cut (1983)

Maybe read this blog post before smashing your computer screen in anger at the ranking of this album. Roger Waters basically made this album himself: David Gilmour sings lead vocals on just one track, Nick Mason’s influence is microscopic, and Richard Wright was not even in the band at the time. However, what this album lacks in unity of the band, it makes up for with its deep and complex themes. Seriously, click this for an in depth, track by track look at this full-fledged concept album. The basic premise is a solider that comes home from war to find that he has been betrayed by his government who once promised him a postwar dream. Although he sees all of this betrayal around him, he does not have the nerve to make “the final cut,” and in the end the human race falls victim to self-destruction from war. This album features some great music that, yes, is mainly made by Roger Waters. To start with, “Your Possible Pasts” and “One of the Few” were originally recorded to be on The Wall, and they work well in the context of either album. “Southampton Dock” is a beautiful acoustic track about sending soldiers off to war after war, and “Two Suns In the Sunset” is another acoustic track with a lasting message. The one track with David Gilmour on lead vocals, “Not Now John” is a rocking single that was a hit in its own right and “The Fletcher Memorial Home” is starkly critical of politicians. “The Post War Dream” is a sad, retrospective track that has us all shouting, “What happened to the postwar dream?” On the title track we learn the true feelings of the soldier. One of the highlights of the album is on “The Gunner’s Dream” when the word “dream” merges in an almost unnoticeable way into a saxophone. This album may be representative of the growing tensions and eventual downfall of the band, but it is certainly a brilliant album and worthy of its place on the list.

5. Meddle (1971)

At number 11, I said we were getting to the upper tier of Pink Floyd albums, but now we are in the upper, upper tier. This was the band’s first great album. They had begun to experiment like never before, and this is the most grounded and unpretentious you will find the band. The music just seems to confidently fall in place on this album. Whether it be the instrumental mesh of organ and guitar on “One of These Days” or the dreamy and lulling “Pillow of Winds,” the band experiments on this album with a self-assurance that would only continue to increase in the coming years. For really the first time ever, we saw what the band was capable of when they all worked together as one. In fact, apart from Waters’ “San Tropez,” the entire album was co-written by multiple members of the band – a trend we would see continue in the coming years. “Fearless” is one of the band’s greatest ever songs, and its mellow acoustic sound and soothing Gilmour vocals just capture you in a way that no other Floyd song had done until this point. Then, there is “Echoes,” which somehow finds a way to keep you engaged for 23 minutes with entertaining guitar riffs, hypnotizing organ and drum sections, beautiful harmonies from Gilmour and Wright, and creepy, echoing noises. It is truly an example of all four members of the band working together to create something beautiful. If Atom Heart Mother gave Pink Floyd their direction, this album gave them their footing.

4. Animals (1977)

It only gets harder and harder to rank these Pink Floyd albums. At this point, any of these albums are good enough to be considered the best, and if 99% of the bands to ever exist released one of these albums, they would hands down be their number 1. But, this is Pink Floyd were talking about, so somehow this album ends up at number 4. Inspired by George Orwell’s Animal Farm, Roger Waters and David Gilmour use a similar sort of satire to criticize British society. Well, I say Waters and Gilmour, but actually “Dogs” was the only track with Gilmour as a co-writer. By this time, Waters had begun to take his role as the head man. On “Dogs” we hear about the rich who seem to only care for themselves, and they will do whatever it takes to get on top. Ultimately, though, they are just slowly being dragged down by “the stone.” “Dogs” also features some of, if not the best guitar work the world has ever seen from David Gilmour. 17 minutes of beautifully satirical lyrics and guitar solos: what could be better? “Pigs (Three Different Ones)” holds nothing back as it criticizes politicians, calling them a “charade.” Waters’ vocals are mixed in with several guitar and bass solos to excellent effect. “Sheep” talks about the rest of society as mere bystanders to the growing unease caused by the “dogs” and “pigs.” However, Waters gives hope for these sheep who eventually rebel against the dogs. “Sheep” takes advantage of synthesizers and mixes these sounds with some rocking bass and guitar to create a feeling of rebellion. “Pigs on the Wing” bookends the album. It is truly a beautiful acoustic track, and is the closest thing Pink Floyd has ever written to a love song. The final message, seen on “Pigs on the Wing, Pt. 2,” is that if you find people you care about, you do not have to worry about “pigs” or “the stone.” This album’s claim to fame is its complex and complete message and its long, sheering, unmatched guitar solos.

3. The Dark Side of the Moon (1973)

This is the quintessential Pink Floyd album. It is one of the greatest selling albums of all-time, and its logo has become a part of mainstream pop culture. It is the perfect Pink Floyd album; this is it – the band at their peak. There will never be anything created quite like it. Its theme and message are incomparably deep and complex. Musically, it is the perfect combination of Waters, Gilmour, Wright, and Mason coming together to create a final product. Thematically, It explores everything about life: birth into the world, time and growing old, religion, money and greed, selfishness, war, mental illness, and more. Some of the band’s most popular and widely praised songs ever appear on this album. In every way, this album is perfect. How are there two albums ahead of a perfect album?

2. Wish You Were Here (1975)

An album better than The Dark Side of the Moon? Oh yeah. For 44 minutes, you are not just engaged with what you are listening to, you are living in the music. The best example of this is “Shine on You Crazy Diamond” which is actually split up to bookend the album. The song that was written for Syd Barret by Roger Waters has the ability to engage you, no, live inside of you for eight minutes without even singing a single lyric. I know I said “Dogs” may feature the best guitar work from Gilmour, but this song might have it beat. The instrumental part culminates when Gilmour passionately sings the meaningful lyrics, and you just feel every single one of them. At that point, you are not just listening to the music, you are experiencing it. “Welcome to the Machine” and “Have a Cigar” are also excellent tracks that criticize the faceless side of the music industry. The lyrics of both of these tracks are perfectly satirical and they mesh in with some beautiful synthetic noises and guitar solos. Once again, you are enthralled in what you are listening to. The deeper meaning behind these tracks lifts you off your feet. The title track is maybe the band’s most popular song, and, I know I have said it so many times, but you are really living this song when you listen to it. Every strum of the guitar and every lyric just seems to pulse throughout your body when you listen to this song. How could there possibly be a better album than this one?

1. The Wall (1979)

Does this album represent the band at its peak level of music-making? No. Is this album primarily composed by Roger Waters with very little input from any of the other members? Yes. Was Richard Wright literally fired towards the end of the recording of this album? Yes. So is this an unorthodox pick for the number 1 Pink Floyd album? Maybe, but The Wall is not only the best Pink Floyd album to ever be created, it is also the greatest album of all-time to ever be created. There exists no other album created in history that has as many moments that blow your mind away as this one. Click here for an in depth, track by track look at the album, but the basic premise is that a boy named Pink Floyd, who is largely based off of Roger Waters, builds a metaphorical wall around himself to isolate himself from those around him. He slowly goes insane and loses touch with his fans. In the end, he eventually realizes that he has been at fault for much his life and he tears down his wall. Instead of deeply analyzing this 1 hour and 21 minutes of pure brilliance, I will instead talk about some of the many mind-blowing moments from this album. The opening riff on “In the Flesh?” hits you right away and puts you in the zone. The end of “The Happiest Days of Our Lives” sets you right into the catchy number 1 hit solo, “Another Brick In the Wall, Pt. 2.” “Mother” gets acoustic but does a purely brilliant job of utilizing both Waters and Gilmour’s voices as different characters in the song. “Young Lust” interrupts the gloomy mood of “Empty Spaces” to give a look into the sex, drugs, and rock and roll of Pink’s Rock Star life. Halfway through “One of My Turns” the guitar kicks in and things start to break as Pink goes crazy. “Goodbye Cruel World” really feels like a goodbye as Pink encloses himself behind his wall. “Hey You” gives us a brilliant guitar solo and smashes any glimmer of hope of getting past the wall. “Is There Anybody Out There?” screams out for help with a longing, hollow, echoing four lines. “Nobody Home” puts you right in the place of Pink as he sits alone behind the wall. “Bring the Boys Back Home” builds up impeccably into “Comfortably Numb” on what is maybe the greatest moment of the album. The beginning riff from “In the Flesh” comes in once again in full force and gets you going just like it did at the beginning of the album. “Run Like Hell” has you wanting to crazy and start rioting in the streets, only for “Waiting for the Worms” to come in and juxtapose these previous ambitions. “Stop” leads beautifully into “The Trial.” Everything we have heard so far comes under review and BOOM the wall comes down. “Outside the Wall” is probably the best track on the album. Here is an in depth post about its message. If you trace the story line as you listen to this album, each one of these moments is truly mind blowing. When you listen to this album, you are not just listening, you are not even just experiencing it, you are painting it within your mind. Each track builds on the last and transitions into the next. As you listen to the album, you see, feel, and touch everything that is going on in your mind. When you listen to The Wall, you are inside the music. No other album that I know of can do what this one can.

Pink Floyd’s Reminder to You During Quarantine (Time)

The Corona Virus Pandemic has affected everyone in different ways. To a lot of people, the pandemic has meant sitting around at home, waiting for it to end, and wishing for better times. Even though the song was written 47 years before the pandemic, “Time,” off of Pink Floyd’s notorious eighth studio album, The Dark Side of the moon, gives us a few things to keep in mind during these troubling times.

“Ticking away the moments that make up a dull day
Fritter and waste the hours in an offhand way.
Kicking around on a piece of ground in your home town
Waiting for someone or something to show you the way.
Tired of lying in the sunshine staying home to watch the rain.
You are young and life is long and there is time to kill today.”

Although they probably did not know it 47 years ago, Pink Floyd is directly describing all of us during quarantine. We are all sitting at home, “ticking away the moments that make up a dull day.” Truly, each of these days during quarantine feels like a dull day. The quarantine is long, and “there is time to kill today.”

“And then one day you find ten years have got behind you.
No one told you when to run, you missed the starting gun.”

Pink Floyd is now telling us that one day we are all going to realize that this time in quarantine has flown by. We spent the whole time waiting for it to end, but little did we realize how much of life we missed in the process.

“So you run and you run to catch up with the sun but it’s sinking
Racing around to come up behind you again.
The sun is the same in a relative way but you’re older,
Shorter of breath and one day closer to death.
Every year is getting shorter never seem to find the time.
Plans that either come to naught or half a page of scribbled lines.”

This is Pink Floyd’s warning to us about what will happen if we just waste away the time we have in quarantine. One day, we are going to realize all the time that has gone by in our lives; we will realize all of the small moments that we missed. We will think about quarantine and all the things we could have done instead of just wishing it was over. We will realize how little time we have to do the things we want, and we will think about quarantine and how we seemed to have unlimited time then.

So what is Pink Floyd telling us to do? They are telling us to try and appreciate the time in quarantine, no matter how difficult it may be. Make your time in quarantine productive. Do something: become closer with your family, start a new hobby, create something, etc. Do not just count down the hours in the day and long for the end. In quarantine, we seem to have too much time, but some day you will be longing for any time at all. Don’t waste it away.

A Track by Track Listening Guide to Pink Floyd’s The Wall

Pink Floyd’s The Wall is widely considered one of Pink Floyd’s greatest works. Largely based off of the events of Roger Waters’ own life, the album traces the life of a boy named Pink Floyd who builds a metaphoric wall around himself, isolating himself from society. Here is a track by track guide to help guide you through the story as you listen:

“In The Flesh?”

This track is an intro to the album; it’s a sort of look into Pink’s future which we will later see on the track with the same name. “If you wanna find out what’s behind these cold eyes, you’ll just have to claw your way through this disguise.” You are now getting an in depth look into the character from the beginning of his life. It’s non linear storytelling.

“The Thin Ice”

This is Pink’s birth. Society in the post WW2 age is compared to a lake of thin ice, and it’s not surprising that someone like Pink could slip through this thin ice with “fear flowing out behind.”

“Another Brick In the Wall, Pt. 1”

This is all about Pink’s father who died in the war when he was very young. All he knows of him is a “snapshot in the family album.” His childhood without a father is just another “brick” in his metaphoric wall.

“The Happiest Days of Our Lives”

This is a sarcastically named song. It’s sort of an intro to another brick in the wall pt 2 but it’s basically saying that childhood is supposed to be the happiest days of one’s life, but for Pink this was not the case.

“Another Brick In the Wall, Pt. 2”

This is about how Pink feels that his teachers were always trying to control their students and mold them to be mindless rule-followers. Pink is essentially saying, ‘F You’ to this, but, once again, his school life and teachers were just bricks in the wall

“Mother”

This is a track about Pink’s overbearing mother: “Mamas gonna check out all your girlfriends for you.” Once again he mentions how it’s just more bricks in the wall: “of course mama’s gonna help build the wall.” The last line of this track is like a cry out to his mother: “mother did it need to be so high….”

“Goodbye Blue Sky”

This song is heavily political and talks about growing up in a post WW2/Cold War era with constant fear of being bombed. “The flames are all long gone but the pain lingers on,” in other words the war has ended but they are still suffering.

“Empty Spaces”

Much of this song was actually cut from the original album, but the full version is in the film and can be found online. Basically, it’s Pink saying that he has so many empty spaces in his life—no father for example—and he needs something to fill it with.

“Young Lust”

This track is Pink living in his Rock Star lifestyle: sex, drugs, and rock and roll. The end of this track includes an important phone call; the phone operator is trying to reach Mrs. Floyd (Pink’s wife), but when the phone is picked up, a man answers the phone and immediatley hangs up. Pink’s wife is sleeping with another man.

“One of My Turns”

This leads perfectly into “One of My Turns.” Pink has just found out about his wife sleeping with another man. Another groupie comes to Pink’s apartment. She is looking around thew room while Pink stares blankly at the tv, showing no emotion. Finally, Pink starts singing about love turning gray and all of a sudden goes berserk and starts breaking everything. The groupie runs away and calls the cops.

“Don’t Leave Me Now”

This track is Pink longing for his wife. We also find out that pink was quite an abusive husband: “I need you to beat to a pulp on a Saturday night.”

“Another Brick In the Wall, Pt. 3”

Pink’s wife leaving him is yet another brick in the wall. At this point, Pink has essentially gone insane, but he does not think he needs any drugs to calm him.

“Goodbye Cruel World”

No, this is not a song about Pink’s suicide. This is actually where he completes his wall. He’s saying goodbye to society in complete isolation.

“Hey You”

This is Pink sort of calling out for help. He is thinking theoretically of someone standing out there behind his wall to help him. However, “it was only fantasy, the wall was too high, as you can see.” Pink realizes his own lonesomeness: “together we stand, divided we fall.”

“Is There Anybody Out There?”

This song only contains the same line repeated four times, but it does an excellent job detailing Pink’s lonesomeness and insanity as he cries out for help.

“Nobody Home”

“I’VE GOT A LITTLE BLACK BOOK WITH MY POEMS IN.” Pink is alone with nothing to do. He has “a strong urge to fly…but nowhere to fly to.” At this point he has gone insane, and he is extremely alone.

“Vera”

This song is a reference to a singer named Vera Lynn who had a hit song called “We’ll Meet Again,” which gave people at home hope that they will see their husbands/fathers again when they come back from the war. Pinks looks at this song with a dead father and cries out, “Vera, Vera, What has become of you?”

“Bring the Boys Back Home”

This is an extremely important track leading into “Comfortably Numb.” It starts with soldiers returning home from the war (of course, Pink’s father is not returning home), and it ends with a bunch of sounds from Pink’s life—the teacher, the groupie, etc. It all builds up and culminates with a big “Is there anybody out there…”

“Comfortably Numb”

BOOM! This track is the turning point of the album. This is when Pink is given drugs to keep him performing (remember he is still a Rock Star). It’s about drugs yes, but it’s also about pink becoming someone he’s not, yet feeling totally comfortable in his mindless state.

“The Show Must Go On”

This is Pink conceding that he’s given up his individualism. He is no longer himself, but “the show must go on.” “Where has the feeling gone?” “Will I remember this song?” “I didn’t mean to let them take my soul.” Pink has lost himself.

“In the Flesh”

Here we are now, back to where we started at the beginning of the album. Everything else has sort of just been a ‘wanna know how I got here?’ sort of thing. This track is actually based of a real event in Waters’ life. When the band was touring, performing Animals, Waters felt very distant from his audience. He felt they did not really appreciate his music, and he actually ended up spitting at them. In this song, Pink basically says he’s gonna find out who his true fans are, and he is going to make them into who he wants them to be (almost Hitler like), and anyone who opposes him is not welcome.

“Run Like Hell”

Pink has become a Hitler-like figure to his audience. The fans are no longer individuals; they are just pawns in Pink’s dictator-like rule. They begin committing acts of theft, murder, and rape in his name. Pink has created a monster.

“Waiting for the Worms”

This song is a realization of what Pink has done. The worms are a metaphor used throughout the album, and they basically symbolize Pink’s rotting away behind his wall. At this point, Pink sort of starts to see all that he has caused. He sits behind his wall, asking himself a series of questions about what he has caused. He is too far gone; at this point, he is just “waiting for the worms.”

“Stop”

This song abruptly cuts off “Waiting for the Worms” because Pink cannot let this go on any longer. His whole life he has blamed others and called them bricks in his wall, but, finally, he must see: “Have I been guilty all this time?”

“The Trial”

Pink puts himself on trial here. He is the judge. He begins to reflect on all parts of his life. We hear testimonies from the teacher, his mother, his wife, etc. Finally, the verdict is that the wall must come down. Pink is sentenced to be “exposed before your peers.”

“Outside the Wall”

This is the most important part of the album. Its the final message. I have a blog post that goes in depth into this track here, but it can be summed up with this line: “The ones who really love you walk up and down outside the wall.”

Roger Waters and The Quiet American: A Hope for a Stop to War

Recently, in my English class, I was tasked with reading a book called, The Quiet American, by Graham Greene. As I read this book, I saw some striking similarities between its message and that of The Wall, The Final Cut, and some of Roger Waters’ solo work. Whether you have read the book or not, it’s an interesting read:

War crowns no winners; it only creates losers. War has plagued the Earth since the
dawning of the human race. Defined most simply as a state of armed conflict, war has been the
source of so much evil throughout history. Especially in the past one hundred years, war has
destroyed lives, ruined families, corrupted children, destroyed nations, and killed hundreds of
millions of ordinary people. A novel by Graham Greene entitled, The Quiet American, details a
state of war within the context of French colonization in Vietnam in 1955. It is told from the
perspective of a man named Fowler who, being a journalist, is not affiliated with any side of the
armed conflict. He meets an American agent named Pyle who thinks he can stop the conflict;
Fowler watches as Pyle tries, but his attempts ultimately result in his death. Greene’s up-close
and personal depiction of war mirrors that of musician Roger Waters in many of his songs. In
two of his albums for his former band Pink Floyd, The Wall (1979) and The Final Cut (1983),
and one of his more recent solo works, Is This the Life We Really Want? (2017), Roger Waters
uses his lyrics to comment on war. Both Green and Waters explain how war brings about fear,
guilt, and a need to take a side, all of which have adverse affects on everyone involved.

Graham Greene depicts the fear throughout Vietnam and explains how it changes the very
perception of life itself. Fear rings throughout Vietnam during this conflict; grenades go off to
the point that hearing one is all too commonplace. Men, women, and children are dying at such a rate that death seems inevitable. Indeed, as Fowler depicts, “From childhood I had never
believed in permanence, and yet I had longed for it. Always I was afraid of losing happiness.
This month, next year…Death was the only absolute value in my world…I envied those who
could believe in a God and I distrusted them. I felt they were keeping their courage up with a
fable of the changeless and the permanent. Death was far more certain than God” (Greene 27-28
of 119). To Fowler, death is a matter of when and how. The question is no longer about why
people must die, instead it is “Why can’t one choose one’s death?” (Greene 66 of 119). This idea
has been driven into Fowler because of the fear he has experienced in his life. Greene uses
Fowler’s attitude to expose war as the culprit for such a common feeling among many.

In a similar fashion, Roger Waters uses Pink Floyd’s 1979 album, The Wall, to give
insight into the fear felt during wartime. The Wall is an autobiographical concept album. It
depicts Waters’ father dying in the war when Waters is very young and Waters growing up in
Britain in a post World War II era through a character called Pink. The war has left a lasting fear
across Britain; this fear is poured into Pink from a young age. The second track of the album,
“The Thin Ice,” is about Pink’s birth into a world of fear: “If you should go skating on the thin
ice of modern life dragging behind you the silent reproach of a million tear-stained eyes, don’t be
surprised when a crack in the ice appears under your feet. You slip out of your depth and out of
your mind with your fear flowing out behind you as you claw the thin ice” (Pink Floyd, The
Wall). Modern life is compared to a lake of ice that has been thinned out by millions in society
who are suffering because of the war. It is unsurprising, then, that one may slip through this ice
and fall into an abyss of fear. Waters explains that this inevitable fear is caused by the war: “The
flames are all long gone, but the pain lingers on” (Pink Floyd, The Wall, “Goodbye Blue Sky”). Much like Fowler, Pink has had fear driven into him by the war. Pink’s baptism of fear factors
into his eventual insanity as depicted later in the album. War is guilty for Pink’s madness; war is
also guilty for bringing about another disturbing emotion: guilt.

Greene demonstrates how guilt taints war, even in times of victory. Fowler depicts his
perspective after traveling alongside a successful French attack: “We didn’t even wait to see our
victims struggling to survive, but climbed and made for home. I thought again as I had thought
when I saw the dead child at Phat Diem, ‘I hate war’…I put on my earphones for Captain Trouin
to speak to me. He said, ‘We will make a little detour. The sunset is wonderful on the
calcaire’” (Greene 89 of 119). Immediately after the attack, Fowler begins to feel a sinking guilt
for what the French have just done. In the eyes of a military strategist, they have just won; they
are now going to look at a beautiful sunset and bask in their glory. On the inside, however, they
have truly lost. Greene uses this dynamic to showcase how there truly are no winners in a war.
Guilt lives forever.

Another concept that both Greene and Waters explore in the realm of guilt is betrayal. In
war, one fights for the side that they are on and kills the side that they are against. Greene
explores this dynamic when Captain Trouin speaks to Fowler: “The first time I dropped napalm I
thought, this is the village where I was born. That is where M. Dubois, my father’s old friend,
lives. The baker—I was very fond of the baker when I was a child—is running away down there
in the flames I’ve thrown” (Greene 90 of 119). The Captain has no personal hatred towards the
people he drops napalm on; he is only killing them because he has been instructed to by his side
of the conflict, and they have been deemed a part of the other side of the conflict. The Captain
never forgets this guilt he felt the first time he dropped napalm; Greene is showing how the guilt of a betrayal affects a soldier forever. Waters also explores a similar concept in Pink Floyd’s
1983 concept album, The Final Cut. This album is told from the perspective of a retired soldier
who, after the war, expects to be living in the postwar dream that he was promised before the war
began. What he experiences, however, is a life of trauma, paranoia, and hatred for the high
command and British government as they simply continue to wage more war across the world.
On “The Hero’s Return,” the soldier talks about his friend, known simply as the gunner, who
happened to be fighting on the enemy side. The soldier returns home as a war hero in the eyes of
his country: “When we came back from the war, the banners and flags hung on everyone’s door.
We danced and we sang in the street and the church bells rang. But burning in my heart, the
memory smoulders on of the gunner’s dying words on the intercom” (Pink Floyd, The Final Cut).
To his country, this soldier is a hero; he killed the enemy. To him, however, this enemy was his
friend, and no matter how much he is praised or viewed as a hero, he will never escape the guilt
of killing him. Waters speaks further to the guilt of this soldier on the next track, “The Gunner’s
Dream”: “Night after night, going ’round and ’round my brain, his dream is driving me insane. In
the corner of some foreign field, the gunner sleeps tonight. What’s done is done. We cannot just
write off his final scene. Take heed of the dream, take heed” (Pink Floyd, The Final Cut). The
killing of “the gunner” pains this soldier, but what drives him insane is that his friend had the
same postwar dream that he had. Millions of other men lost that postwar dream that they were
promised. Waters utilizes this as the moment, in a similar way to how Greene did, to showcase
that there are truly no winners in war. One either has his dream taken away from him or has it
tainted by the taking of another’s. This guilt is only further compounded by the fact that he had to view his friend as his enemy. That is another thing about war—one must take a side, even
when there is no true good side.

Greene demonstrates the impossibility of remaining neutral during a war, even without
having any desire to join either side. Fowler is a journalist, and as he details accounts from
Vietnam, he talks to people from all sides of the conflict, trying to remain neutral. As the conflict
escalates, however, he finds it impossible not to ally himself in some way. He finds out that his
friend, Pyle, has got himself involved in the war, and he is asked to help him: “Sooner or
later…one has to take sides. If one is to remain human” (Greene 103 of 119). This is a message
straight from Greene: neutrality in a war is not possible. Even in intentionally not helping his
friend in the name of remaining neutral, Fowler still takes a side. Pyle dies, and Fowler knew his
death was going to occur, but chose to do nothing about it. Fowler is asked about Pyle’s death by
an investigator who says he is “just making a report, that’s all. So long as it’s an act of war—
well, there are thousands killed every year.” Fowler responds, “You can rule me out…I’m not
involved. Not involved” (Greene 18 of 119). Fowler’s insistence on staying uninvolved is
exposed here as naivety and ignorance. He chose not to stop the death of his own friend. Greene
drives home the point that no matter what Fowler may think, he is involved. There is no such
thing as being neutral during a war. Inaction is an action in and of itself.

Waters also explores the concept of taking sides. In his 2017 solo album, Is This the Life
We Really Want?, he comments on the state of America in the 21st century, particularly talking
about ongoing conflicts with multiple countries across the world. He describes children of
countries that are enemies of the United States: “It don’t much matter wherever you’re born.
Little babies mean us no harm. They have to be taught to despise us, to bulldoze our homes to the ground, to believe their fight is for liberty, to believe their God will keep them safe and
sound” (Waters, Is This the Life We Really Want?, “Broken Bones”). This is true of American
children as well. All children, in some way, are taught from birth to hate certain people. Like
Greene, Waters expresses that complete neutrality is impossible. Waters, however has a vision
for the future: “We cannot turn back the clock, cannot go back in time, but we can say ‘fuck you,’
we will not listen to your bullshit and lies” (Waters, Is This the Life We Really Want?, “Broken
Bones”). Unlike his character in The Final Cut, who “never had the nerve to make the final cut,”
21st Century Waters believes that this taking of sides and never ending cycle of war can be
broken if people are able to recognize the hatred that has been encoded in them by their country
and political leaders (Pink Floyd, The Final Cut, “The Final Cut”).

At their cores, both The Quiet American and Roger Waters’ albums are anti-war works.
Both Greene and Waters provide an extremely honest look into war in order to expose it for what
it is: and endless and winner-less cycle of fighting and killing. They expose political leaders and
high ranking officers for caring very little about their own men and the millions of ordinary lives
lost. Greene gets his message across through Captain Trouin when he says, “We are
professionals: we have to go on fighting till the politicians tell us to stop. Probably they will get
together and agree to the same peace that we could have had at the beginning, making nonsense
of all these years” (Greene 91 of 119). Greene exposes war for being pretty much useless; the
outcome is never really much different from what was before. Waters gets his message across on
the track “The Fletcher Memorial Home” from The Final Cut when he describes political leaders
and high ranking officers: “They can polish their medals and sharpen their smiles, and amuse
themselves playing games for awhile. Boom boom, bang bang, lie down you’re dead. Safe in the permanent gaze of a cold glass eye with their favorite toys” (Pink Floyd). Waters exposes
political leaders and high ranking officers for “playing games” when it comes to war and viewing
it as no more than “boom boom, bang bang.” He exposes them for only caring about their shiny
medals and for continuing war for amusement.

War creates fear, guilt, and a need to take a side. These things haunt children, civilians,
and soldiers alike. War itself is unending. Winning one war only means needing to eventually
fight in another. There are no winners in war anyways. If war and conflict are ever to end, the
world must say “fuck you” to implicit hatred. The world must recognize the affect that war has
on every single person. War is not a necessary evil; intervention is certainly important, but the
need to declare full-scale war and all-out hatred for a country has never, and will never, exist.
The cycle of war can be stopped. To end war, the world must finally “understand the feelings of
the few: Ashes and diamonds, foe and friend, we were all equal in the end” (Pink Floyd, The
Final Cut, “Two Suns in the Sunset”).

Works Cited

Greene, Graham. The Quiet American. Open Road Integrated Media, 2018, iTunes.
Pink Floyd. The Wall, Harvest Records, Columbia Records, 1979.
Pink Floyd. The Final Cut, Harvest Records, Columbia Records, 1983.
Waters, Roger. Is This the Life We Really Want?, Columbia Records, 2017.

Atom Heart Mother: The Album When Pink Floyd Found Their Direction

When Syd Barrett left Pink Floyd in 1968, the band struggled to find its direction. In the early days of Floyd, Barrett was the catalyst. Early pop hit singles like “Arnold Layne” and “See Emily Play” were works of his, and the band’s debut album, The Piper at the Gates of Dawn, was almost entirely written by him.

Under his heavy use of psychedelic drugs, Syd Barrett drove himself to insanity. In 1968, David Gilmour was brought into the band as the lead guitarist, and shortly after, during the recording of Pink Floyd’s second studio album, Syd Barrett was ousted from the band. He was in no state to continue recording and performing with the band.

Floyd’s first two albums are generally viewed as quite excellent albums. The Piper at the Gates of Dawn introduced the world to the band’s psych-pop style, and A Saucerful of Secrets saw the band transition into a psychedelic space-rock style. However, in late 1968 and in 1969, the band greatly struggled without their front man. Roger Waters had not yet become the driving songwriting that we know him as today, Richard Wright struggled to really capture the brilliance that he had showed alongside Syd Barrett, and David Gilmour’s influence had yet to be fully felt. The band was at a loss. Their next two studio albums were generally considered some of their worst.

The first post-Syd album was actually barely even a studio album. More is the soundtrack to a relatively unknown film. The psychedelic style of Pink Floyd is hardly seen on this album, and the absence of Syd is certainly felt. However, it does function like a soundtrack, so it is hard to really judge the band based off this album.

Ummagumma is the first true post-Syd album. If I could describe this album in two words it would be: random noises. It’s creepy and weird and not very music-like at all. It feels like the band is trying to recreate that weird Syd Barrett sound, but they forgot to actually make it music. Just go listen to the track titled, “Several Species of Small Furry Animals Gathered Together in a Cave and Grooving With a Pict,” and you will know what I am talking about. At this point, the band just seemed lost.

David Gilmour & Roger Waters during the recording of Atom Heart ...

Just under a year after this monstrosity, the band released Atom Heart Mother. How the band was able to go from Ummagumma to this album is beyond me. In eleven months, they somehow go from an album full of random noises to their first ever number 1 album in the UK. Atom Heart Mother is the album that set Pink Floyd on the path to what we would see later in their discography. Without it, there would be no Dark Side of the Moon or Animals.

Unlike their previous work, Atom Heart Mother has a clearly defined structure. Somewhere along those 11 months, the band realized that sticking some random series of noises and a couple of live tracks on an album was not a good idea.

The albums starts with its title track, which was composed by all four members. This 23:44 track takes up the entire first side of the record, and it is a six-part suite. It features some brilliant horn sections (something we would never see on another Floyd album), beautiful choir parts, and some excellent Gilmour guitar riffs. The next four tracks were then composed by each of the members individually.

Roger Waters’ “If” is a beautiful acoustic track. Seriously, just compare this track to his “Grantchester Meadows” from Ummagumma, which was one of the few actual songs from the album, and the difference is simply extraordinary. “If” is lyrically mature, and it even begins to touch on some themes that we would see in Floyd’s later albums.

Richard Wright’s “Summer ’68” is an extremely fun pop song. I am struggling to fathom how this song could have come just 11 months after a song like “Sysyphus.” It has a fun chorus, beautiful verses, and wait what’s that? Structure? Where was this 11 months ago?

You could say that “Fat Old Sun” is David Gilmour’s first real contribution to the band. He certainly had influence beforehand, but “Fat Old Sun” was the first great track that he created. Only took him two years! It’s beautiful and acoustic, and the lyrics are really quite brilliant as well. Again, how was something like “The Narrow Way” released on the album just before this track?

Nick Mason’s contribution to this album is “Alan’s Psychedelic Breakfast.” This track is much closer to what we saw on Ummagumma. It is mostly just some random noises, but it has some parts where I actually felt like it was a song, so that is quite the step up.

All in all, Atom Heart Mother gave Pink Floyd direction. From here they would go on to create Meddle which was yet another massive step up. Just a couple of years later they would release their greatest ever accomplishment, The Dark Side of the Moon, and the rest is history.

Pink Floyd recording Dark Side of The Moon. Happy 46th anniversary ...

Pink Floyd Listening Guide: What Album You Should Listen to Next

This list is my opinion on the order that Pink Floyd’s albums should be listened to in. This list is not a ranking of every Pink Floyd album, and ultimately you can listen in whatever order you want. It is important, however, to listen to albums as wholes. If you have never listened to Pink Floyd before, here is how I would start…

The Dark Side of the Moon (1973)

This is the quintessential Pink Floyd album. When someone says Pink Floyd, you think of Dark Side. The album is a perfect 43 minute-long concept album about every aspect of life. This is the band at their absolute peak, and it also starts a run of about 7 years of pure creative brilliance from the band.

Wish You Were Here (1975)

This album follows Dark Side in Floyd’s discography. This is an easy next album to listen to because, once again, the band is at their peak. This album is dedicated to former band member Syd Barrett, and it explores themes about the lack of humanity in the music industry.

Animals (1977)

Let’s go to the next album in this 7 year period of brilliance. Animals continues the streak of brilliantly conceived concept albums. It uses similar metaphors to that of George Orwell’s Animal Farm to criticize British society.

The Wall (1979)

This is the last album in that 7 year period of brilliance. About 99% of Pink Floyd fans will have these albums, in some order, as their top four. The Wall differs slightly from the previous three, both musically and thematically. It is a double record that traces the life of a boy named Pink as he slowly builds a metaphoric wall around himself, shutting himself off from society. There was also a film released in 1982 that accompanies this album.

The Final Cut (1983)

Remember, this list is not a ranking of the Pink Floyd albums. The reason you should listen to The Final Cut next is because it is musically and thematically similar to The Wall. Some of the tracks on this album were actually originally recorded to be on The Wall. You could probably skip over this one, but it is an enjoyable concept album about a World War II veteran. Just keep in mind when you listen that this album is more or less a Roger Waters solo album.

Meddle (1971)

Now it is time to go back and listen to Pink Floyd before their 7 year peak period. The best place to start is Meddle. We are not really going to see anymore crazy deep concept albums, but musically we will not be disappointed. Meddle is a musical masterpiece, and it was a huge step up for the band. The music is still somewhat similar to what we have been hearing

Atom Heart Mother (1970)

The album right before Meddle was also a very big creative step for the band. Once again, the music is not all that different from what we have been listening to, so its a good next step. Well, some of the music at least. Listening to this album will definitely introduce you to the weirder side of Pink Floyd, which we will definitely see a lot more of.

The Piper at the Gates of Dawn (1967)

I think it is time that we were introduced to a man named Syd Barrett. Yes, the same guy that Wish You Were Here is dedicated to. This album is the brainchild of Syd Barrett’s LSD-driven madness. It is quite different from what we have been listening to, and David Gilmour was not even in the band at this time, but it embodies the early psych-pop era of Pink Floyd.

A Saucerful of Secrets (1968)

This album is perfect to listen to right after The Piper at the Gates of Dawn. This is the first album with David Gilmour and the last with Syd Barrett. The fading psych-pop influence of Syd Barrett can still be seen in some parts, and the slowly evolving space-rock side of the band can be seen in others.

The Division Bell (1994)

Now we teleport ahead almost thirty years to the post-Waters era of Pink Floyd. They released three albums without Waters, and this one is certainly the most noteworthy. His absence is certainly felt, but this album is still worth listening to. Nick Mason and Richard Wright were fully present for the first time since Waters left, and it really feels like one final performance for the band.

Obscured By Clouds (1972)

At this point, we have explored every era of Floyd’s discography, so we will just go back and look at some of the albums that we skipped over. Obscured By Clouds was actually released in between Meddle and The Dark Side of the Moon, so the band was certainly at a creative high point. It was originally conceived to be a soundtrack to a movie, however, and at times it feels this way, almost restraining their creativity. It still has some excellent moments that make it worth listening to though.

Ummagumma (1969)

I guarantee that this is one of the weirdest things you will ever listen to. There are a few live tracks on here, and a couple actual songs, and the rest is basically just random noises. It is sort of representative of the band being lost without Syd Barrett, but it is still worth listening to just because of how different it is.

A Momentary Lapse of Reason (1987)

At this point, you have gotten the Pink Floyd experience, and you can probably just stop, but I will comment briefly on the last three albums. A Momentary Lapse of Reason was the first post-Waters album. Nick Mason and Richard Wright just sort of joined in towards the end so they could slap Pink Floyd on the album, so it is sort of just a David Gilmour solo work.

The Endless River (2014)

This album is just some instrumental scraps from their last session. It’s either a tribute to Richard Wright after his death or a way to make some more money, I am not sure which.

More (1969)

Some do not even consider this a studio album. It’s the soundtrack to a little-known film, and it feels somewhat out of place in Pink Floyd’s discography. It is officially the first album without Syd Barrett, though, so that is kind of interesting.

Outside The Wall: Roger Waters’ Message To Us All

“All alone, or in two’s
The ones who really love you
Walk up and down outside the wall
Some hand in hand
And some gathered together in bands
The bleeding hearts and the artists
Make their stand
And when they’ve given you their all
Some stagger and fall, after all its not easy
Banging your heart against some mad bugger’s wall”

Roger Waters

On November 30, 1979, Pink Floyd released their eleventh studio album titled The Wall. The album is a concept album like no other. It follows the story of a character named Pink Floyd, who is largely based off of Roger Waters. Pink deals with a lot of tough times in his life including the loss of his father, an overprotective mother, teachers who try to control him, a failed marriage, an obsession with a rock star lifestyle, etc. These experiences lead him to build a metaphoric wall around himself, isolating himself from society and those closest to him. He begins to lose sight of who he is; he ends up doing drugs and molding his fans into an almost Nazi-like cult. He and his fans end up causing a great deal of pain and suffering. It is not until Pink finally realizes that he is the one to blame for all of this suffering that he is able to tear down this “wall” and find himself again.

“Outside the Wall” is the final track on the album, and it is too often forgotten about. The lyrics are sung so quietly that you really have to crank up the volume to even hear them, but on this 1 hour 21 minute long double record, the final 1:44 is by far the most important. It is the “so what?” of The Wall. The album is nothing without it.

Every single one of us, in some way, can relate to The Wall. We all isolate ourselves from something or someone at some point. Whether it be a truth we refuse to face, a friend or family member, a spouse, or even one’s faith, we are all guilty of doing what Pink did in some way. We often sit in our own loneliness, feeling sorry for ourselves, blaming others or other things for the position we are in, or refusing to try and address our issues. We sit behind a wall away from the judgement of others.

Waters’ message is clear: In order to tear down the wall, you must accept your own faults and failures; you cannot go on blaming others for your problems, and you must face your problems head on. Waters tells us that outside of our walls there are people who really love us and want to help us. While we sit behind our walls of isolation and constrained feelings, others are literally banging their hearts against our walls, trying to get through to help us. It is not always easy for these people; sometimes they stagger and fall, but they really do love you. There are people who want to help you.

At the very end of the track we can hear him say very faintly, “Isn’t this where…” If we then go back to the start of the first track of the album, “In the Flesh?,” we can here him faintly say at the beginning of that track, “we began?” This makes The Wall a circular album, and Waters does this to show that we will continue to build walls over and over again in our lives. Our whole lives are filled with building up and tearing down walls, but we are to never forget that “the one’s who really love you walk up and down outside the wall.”

The Final Cut: The Most Misunderstood and Underappreciated Pink Floyd Album (A Track by Track Analysis)

Overview

The Final Cut was released in 1983 and was the final Pink Floyd album released before the initial breakup of the band. It has been the subject of much hate and criticism from many Floyd fans over the years. In my opinion, however, The Final Cut is an excellent concept album with a strong and impactful message.

The Final Cut has taken understandable criticism. First of all, it can hardly even be labelled a “Pink Floyd Album.” The album was entirely conceived by Roger Waters. Richard Wright was not even in the band at the time, Nick Mason just played a couple of sound effects here and there, and David Gilmour sings on just one of the tracks. The rest is all Waters. Second, The Final Cut is, in many ways, the last straw in the band’s breakup. There was a lot of tension between Waters and Gilmour during these sessions, and it ultimately resulted in the end of the band. Well, at least for Waters.

While these criticisms are certainly well-founded, this album has been wrongfully written off by some under other criticisms. I have heard this album called “not a full fledged concept album” or “the sequel to The Wall” or “just some leftover tracks from The Wall.” While some of the tracks were originally recorded to be on The Wall, the actual final product functions as a full-fledged concept album with its own unique message.

I understand the criticisms of this album, but when I just focus on the product itself, I find the Final Cut to be one of my favorite Pink Floyd albums of all time.

Track by Track Analysis

The Final Cut is told from the point of view of a British soldier who fought in World War II in hopes of achieving a better postwar world, but he finds that the world he expected to live in is nothing like he had imagined, and he feels betrayed by his government. To clarify a common misconception, Pink from The Wall is nowhere on this album; it is an entirely different story line.

“The Postwar Dream”

This tracks serves as the intro to the album. This is Waters speaking, giving a general overview to the world that this album is set in. He mentions his father: “Was it for this that Daddy died?” He talks about the “nips” or the Japanese and their rising suicide rate after the war. And he mentions “Maggie,” referring to Margaret Thatcher, who was the Prime Minister of England at the time. Waters rhetorically screams out the questions, “What have we done to England,” “What happened to the Postwar Dream?” This sets the tone for the main story line of the album.

“Your Possible Pasts”

We are now being narrated by the main character of this album-the soldier. He starts right away by explaining his, and much of Britain’s, youth. He explains how they were constantly being controlled and molded to be a certain way; they were “shown how to feel good and told to feel bad.” This song was originally written to be on The Wall, and it builds off of the teachers that are detailed on songs like “Another Brick in the Wall Pt. 2,” but it fits well into this album as well. The soldier’s feelings ring out to him, asking “Do you remember me? How we used to be? Do you think we should be closer?” We are introduced to a theme we will see throughout this album-the soldier being out of touch with his feelings.

“One of the Few”

This is a quick track that further builds on teachers trying to control the children and “make ’em do what you want them to.”

“The Hero’s Return”

This tracks brings us up to the soldier’s return home from the war. It starts with the teacher figure touching again on how they tried to mold the kids to be completely emotionless. It then transitions into the perspective of the soldier. He has a “memory that is too painful to withstand the light of day,” but he can only tell his wife this when she is asleep so as not to appear weak. He explains how he was praised by everyone after the war: “When we came back from the war, the banners and flags hung on everyone’s door,” but on the inside he felt only pain because of a man he killed in Dresden, known simply as “The Gunner,” who was his friend.

“The Gunner’s Dream”

This track elaborates on “The Gunner” mentioned in the previous track. The soldier explains the postwar dream throughout the track: the postwar dream that he had, that the gunner had, and that so many others had. Woven in, he details the moment when he killed “The Gunner” (Just take a moment to recognize the brilliance of when Waters sings “and hold on to the dream” and it transitions beautifully into a saxophone). The soldier discloses that his friend’s dream is driving him insane every time he thinks about it. His final message is, “What’s done is done. We cannot just write off his final scene. Take heed of the dream. Take heed.”

“Paranoid Eyes”

On this track, the soldier explains the face he has to put on to those around him. He hides all of his true thoughts and feelings behind a mask. To others, he is a brave war hero, but actually he is just hiding behind paranoid eyes. This track is sort of like an expectation vs. reality of a war hero. This line pretty much sums it up: “You believed in their stories of fame, fortune, and glory. Now you’re lost in a haze of alcohol, soft middle age.”

“Get Your Filthy Hands Off My Desert”

The album now transitions to talk about present day (in the context of 1983) and how more wars are still being fought. This is a short track that references wars going on across the world at the time, including Soviet deployment in Afghanistan, Israel’s invasion of Lebanon, and Britain’s conflict with Argentina.

“The Fletcher Memorial Home”

This track is a searing political message from Waters through the voice of the soldier. This track is bitterly sarcastic, deeply criticizing political leaders for their lack of care for the lives of their soldiers. The soldier accuses them of viewing war as nothing more than “Boom Boom, Bang Bang” and a way to gain medals and political support as they hide “safe in the permanent gaze of a cold glass eye.”

“Southampton Dock”

In a general sense this track is about how soldiers have to go to war again. They came back from World War II, were willing to sacrifice their lives, and saw many of their brothers die in front of their very own eyes, only to be sent out again by their country to fight another war. The final line on this album is the first reference to the main motif of the album: “But in the bottom of our hearts we felt the final cut.” The next track elaborates more on this, but in essence the final cut is an end to war altogether. The soldier sees this broken postwar dream, a constant cycle of more war, and a betrayal by his government, and he wants it all to end.

“The Final Cut”

This track is the culmination of it all. We get a look into the soldier’s true feelings. It is framed as a message to the soldier’s hypothetical future lover. He asks questions like “If I show you my dark side, will you still hold me tonight?…Would you sell your story to Rollingstone?…Would you take the children away and leave me alone?” This once again reflects the sodlier’s conditioning to be emotionless and out of touch with his feelings. He realizes that there really is not a place for these thoughts in the world, even though every soldier really feels the same way. The last few lines of this track are the most important: “Thought I oughta bare my naked feelings. Thought I oughta tear the curtain down. I held the blade in trembling hands, prepared to make it, but just then the phone rang. I never had the nerve to make the final cut.” And so it ends disappointingly. The soldier never had the nerve to share his true feelings about Britain and the war. He could never make “the final cut” by trying to end this cycle of war.

“Not Now John”

This is the one track that features David Gilmour on lead vocals. It was quite a popular single in its own right, but it fits well into this album. This track is told from the perspective of the political leaders and governments that the soldier has been criticizing. It is essentially saying “Fuck all that” to all these anti-war protests because, hey, they have to compete with all of these other countries. This is a very ironic and satirical track exposing these leaders.

“Two Suns in the Sunset”

This is the sad ending to the album. Because the soldier, and so many others, did not have the nerve to make the final cut, this is what the world is. The title “Two Suns in the Sunset” refers to a nuclear bomb explosion, which is so big that it looks like there are actually two suns. The soldier is now living in a nuclear apocalypse, “could be the human race is run.” The soldier’s final message to the listener is truly beautiful: “Finally, I understand the feelings of the few. Ashes and diamonds, foe and friend, we were all equal in the end.”

“When the Tigers Broke Free”

I thought I would just mention this because it is listed as a part of The Final Cut in some places. This song is not a part of the original release and it should viewed as a part of The Wall, especially because it features in the film.

Conclusion

I urge you to look at The Final Cut for its themes and musical brilliance and not be blinded by the growing conflicts within the band. Yes, this is more or less a Roger Waters solo work, but its a great album nonetheless.

The Final Cut has a singular concept, a unique story line, and a beautiful message. This album is still relevant today. As we see more and more conflict and wars fought throughout the world, we should ask ourselves, Do we have the nerve to make the final cut?